James Goss: Doctor Who: City of Death

Doctor Who: City of Death
by James Goss (Douglas Adams contributor, from a story by David Fisher)
(Science-Fantasy, TV novelization)

I think I would have to give this book a 3.5 star rating. If in doubt, round it up because of Goss’ skill in the actual writing of the text. I imagine it could be difficult to make an interesting novelization of a TV show which has the pacing of classic Doctor Who episodes. (Old Who tends to be paced much slower than modern audiences expect. There’s a longer build, and episodes run as serials, with 4 or 5 episodes to one story. New Who is much faster, with each episode usually containing the entire story, even if the season does have a series arc as well. It seems to be hard for fans of New Who to go back and enjoy Old Who episodes because of the pacing difference.)

This is not my favorite Doctor Who episode. Not by a LONG shot. The Fourth Doctor (who is featured in this book) is My Doctor, as Whovians reckon things, but this episode has never been a highlight for me. It seems that The Doctor isn’t the star of this episode – and the star isn’t even his companion, Romana. (Yes, I realize she’s also a Time Lord. She’s still his companion.) The star of this episode is Paris. And that’s not what I enjoy most from Doctor Who episodes.

I have read (well, listened to) another of James Goss’ Doctor Who stories, but this is the only one which was a TV episode first. I liked the other one a lot more, because I was able to enjoy it for itself and not with the episode constantly running in my head as background to the story. (Granted, I also liked it because it was narrated by David Tenant.) This one was well written, but had the same issues that the TV episode did. I don’t read Doctor Who to read about Paris any more than I watch the show for that reason.

I did enjoy the additional background we see into the other characters, and the humor was lovely. My chief complaint is with the plot, and not the execution.

Rating: 4 stars

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

Here Be Wyverns

Posting on Wednesdays for Wyverns, Writing and Weirdness!

Fran Laniado- Author

Welcome to the website of YA Fantasy author Fran Laniado

Bookstooge's Reviews on the Road

Without a Good SFF Book, Life's Road is Hell

K.L. Kranes, Writing Reading Life

Musings of a Sometimes Author

Captain's Quarters

Exploring sci-fi, fantasy, and young adult novels.

The Daily Bailey

Puppy Thoughts and Photo Shots

the orang-utan librarian

welcome to the virtual library

bonnyknits

I play with yarn! And my kids, sometimes.

Dragons & Zombies

A reader lives a thousand lives before he dies. The man who never reads lives only one... (George R. R. Martin, A Dance with Dragons)

Books and Waffles

What's important in life: books, waffles, writing

BookBum

A friendly space for all mystery, crime & thriller lovers

Jo-Creates

Knit one, Crochet too, then go make something to eat!

kmkat & her kneedles

It's about knitting the way Car Talk was about cars.

Tez Says

Tez Miller: Reader. Reviewer. Blogger. Urban Fantasy & Futuristic.

Raelyn Barclay

everyone deserves a happily-ever-after

An Inkophile's Blog

Fountain pens, ink, paper, watercolor and more

Lattes & Llamas

we live for wool and bleed espresso

CharlieFarlie's Cave

Writings, ramblings and rantings

%d bloggers like this: